Use It or Lose It? What Employers Should Know About Unused Vacation Time Before Year-End
As the end of the year approaches, vacation balances deserve a closer look. Many employees are trying to fit in remaining days off before December 31, while employers are balancing holiday schedules, staffing needs, customer demands, and year-end deadlines.
But what happens when employees have accrued vacation time they haven't been able to use? And what if business demands or scheduling restrictions have made it difficult to take time off before the deadline?
A well-defined vacation policy can help employers manage time-off requests while giving employees a reasonable opportunity to enjoy their earned benefits. Before closing out the year, here are a few things to consider.
Is it too late to use remaining vacation time?
Not necessarily. Even in November, there may be opportunities to schedule remaining vacation days before the end of the year.
Employers should encourage employees to review their available balances and submit any outstanding requests as soon as possible. Managers can work with employees to identify available dates, stagger time off, or arrange coverage to accommodate requests without disrupting business operations.
However, not every request can be approved. Employers generally have the discretion to manage vacation schedules based on business needs, including staffing levels, busy seasons, and advance-notice requirements. The key is to apply scheduling rules consistently and without discrimination.
What if business needs prevent employees from using their vacation?
This is where employers should take a closer look at their policies and practices.
For example, an employee may have several vacation days remaining but be unable to schedule time off because of seasonal demands, staffing shortages, or repeated scheduling denials.
If an employer has a use-it-or-lose-it policy, employees may ultimately lose unused time under the policy's terms, where permitted by applicable law. However, employers should consider whether employees have had a reasonable opportunity to use their accrued vacation.
If business needs consistently prevent employees from taking time off, it may be worth considering an exception, allowing additional time to use the balance, or revisiting the company's carryover policy.
A policy should not unintentionally penalize employees for circumstances outside their control.
Are use-it-or-lose-it vacation policies allowed?
It depends on the state. While federal law does not require private employers to provide paid vacation, state laws determine how accrued vacation time can be managed and whether unused balances can be forfeited.
Some states, including California, prohibit use-it-or-lose-it policies because earned vacation is considered wages. Others allow these policies but may have specific requirements for accrual limits, employee notice, and payout upon separation.
Employers should make sure their written policies clearly outline when vacation must be used, whether unused time carries over, and what happens to remaining balances when employment ends.
Not sure what applies to your workforce? Find vacation leave laws by state for a state-by-state overview of use-it-or-lose-it policies, accrual limits, and unused vacation payout requirements.
Should employers consider allowing vacation time to roll over?
For some organizations, a rollover policy may be a better alternative to a strict use-it-or-lose-it approach.
Allowing employees to carry over a reasonable amount of unused vacation time can provide additional flexibility, particularly when business demands make scheduling time off difficult toward the end of the year.
Employers may also consider setting an accrual cap. Rather than forfeiting earned time at the end of the year, an accrual cap limits how much vacation an employee can accumulate. Once the employee reaches the cap, additional time stops accruing until the balance is reduced.
The right approach depends on the organization's staffing needs, benefit structure, and applicable state laws.
Whatever approach an employer chooses, the policy should be clearly communicated and consistently administered.
A Year-End Vacation Policy Checkup
Before the calendar turns to a new year, use this checklist to make sure your vacation policy is clear, consistent, and ready for the year ahead.
☐ Review vacation balances: Identify employees with significant unused vacation time and remind them to check their remaining balances.
☐ Encourage time-off requests: Give employees an opportunity to schedule remaining days and work with managers to coordinate coverage.
☐ Review denied requests: Look for patterns in vacation request denials and determine whether staffing or scheduling practices are preventing employees from using their time.
☐ Check your policy: Review your use-it-or-lose-it provisions, rollover limits, and accrual caps for compliance with applicable state laws.
☐ Plan for the year ahead: Consider whether your current vacation policy provides enough flexibility for both employees and business operations.
☐ Communicate any changes: Notify employees of policy updates before the new benefit year begins and update your employee handbook and related documentation.
Not sure whether your vacation policy is keeping up with your business needs or state requirements? Need help with your HR policies?
Reply a Comment